Anthony Olson needed a profession, kids, a companion with whom he may hike Montana’s trails. Regardless of the diabetes prognosis at age 4, the anemia, the kidney transplant that failed at age 29, the dialysis, he clung to these goals. He attended group school and later moved from his mother and father’ home in Helena to check accounting at Montana Tech in Butte. He thought he would possibly dwell a virtually regular life.
All of that was taken away in early 2011 when an oncologist at St. Peter’s, Helena’s solely hospital, identified him with myelodysplastic syndrome, a blood dysfunction that’s typically described as pre-leukemia. The life expectancy of MDS sufferers is brief. “He instructed me that with out therapy, I’d be useless earlier than the tip of the yr,” Olson stated. He was 33.
“That prognosis modified the course of my life,” Olson, now 47, instructed me.
Olson couldn’t have identified that he was certainly one of many sufferers who, in accordance with court records, could have obtained inappropriate, harmful or unnecessary treatments from Dr. Thomas C. Weiner. As I reported earlier this month, directors at St. Peter’s suspected Weiner, who directed the hospital’s most cancers heart, was hurting sufferers for years. But hospital directors allowed him to maintain treating individuals till late 2020, once they suspended after which fired him. Weiner has denied all of the allegations.
“I trusted that he was doing what was finest for me,” Olson stated of Weiner. “I by no means actually questioned that till another person instructed me that there was motive to.”
I found Olson’s story in a cache of information associated to an ongoing authorized dispute between Weiner and St. Peter’s. I used to be struck by how related his case was to that of one other Weiner affected person, Scot Warwick. Weiner had identified Warwick with Stage 4 lung most cancers and handled him with chemo and different therapies for 11 years, court docket information present; after Warwick died in 2020, his household discovered, from each a biopsy and an post-mortem, that he never had cancer. Weiner insisted that Warwick had most cancers all these years and that different docs “missed” the illness.
Olson’s prognosis was equally flimsy, and he had been handled over almost the identical time frame. However there was a key distinction between the 2 males: Olson lived to inform his story.
Good journalism makes a distinction:
Our nonprofit, unbiased newsroom has one job: to carry the highly effective to account. Right here’s how our investigations are spurring real world change:
We’re making an attempt one thing new. Was it helpful?
After he was identified, Olson dropped out of faculty, moved again in together with his mother and father and started Weiner’s prescribed routine: 4 straight days on chemo, 4 weeks off. Repeat till he died. Olson endured this for 9 years.
“I finished shifting in direction of a profession and a future and was making an attempt to determine, ‘What can I do now? What’s most essential to me?’” Olson stated. “I spent loads of time fascinated about that, however I didn’t actually have the cash, particularly with the price of therapies, to do something. I used to be type of simply caught.”
In our conversations, Olson downplayed what occurred to him subsequent. As chemo goes, he stated he had it simpler than most. He saved most of his hair, for instance. However exhaustion from the chemo anchored him to his mother and father’ basement. He sank into himself, tinkering with computer systems and dabbling in pictures, “reaching for something that I may do in my comparatively quick period of time.” He instructed family members he’d quickly be gone. He requested his mother and father to take his automobile. His father refused.
Early in his therapy, checks confirmed the chemo had worsened Olson’s anemia. Weiner positioned him on weekly iron-rich blood transfusions. Over months after which years of chemotherapy and different therapies, Olson bonded with Weiner and St. Peter’s workers. He considered them as pals. Because the iron ranges in his blood continued to rise, the most cancers heart nurses started calling him “The Iron Man.”
“I believed he was serving to me,” Olson stated of Weiner. “I truly felt fairly lucky that we had such a gifted physician in such a small group.”
His mother and father, too, believed they’d discovered “a miracle” in Weiner. Olson appreciated that Weiner had taken over as his major care doctor. Like dozens of Weiner’s sufferers, Olson instructed me he thought he had discovered a type of concierge different to the damaged maze that’s the American well being care system. Weiner typically fast-tracked sufferers for hospital stays, which made him standard with sufferers. It additionally elevated his affected person load — as many as 70 affected person contacts a day, information present. The extra therapies and visits Weiner billed, the more cash he made.
“He all the time made the method pretty straightforward,” Anthony’s mom, Patti Olson, stated of Weiner. “So, if we wanted drugs or something like that, he would bridge that hole for us. That went a good distance in serving to us via loads of fairly troublesome conditions.”
Credit score:
Louise Johns, particular to ProPublica
In 2016, Dr. Robert LaClair, the kidney specialist who was managing Olson’s dialysis, became concerned. After tons of of blood transfusions, Olson’s physique was affected by “iron overload” (a ferritin degree of over 10,000), which may destroy inner organs. It may have killed him.
LaClair tweaked Olson’s therapies, which improved his anemia and iron overload. He instructed him that he may now be a candidate for a brand new kidney, which might supplant the necessity for dialysis and perhaps enable him to regain his life. The one downside? His chemo therapy disqualified him from the transplant waitlist.
Olson instructed me there have been moments of actual anger at his state of affairs, “however more often than not, I feel I used to be fairly degree, and simply did it as a result of it needed to be completed, and this was the therapy. For lots of it, I used to be amazed that I used to be nonetheless round and that it was working in addition to it was.”
By 2019, LaClair suspected that Weiner could have misdiagnosed Olson and urged his affected person to get a second opinion. However LaClair saved quiet about his misgivings for years, in accordance with information and interviews. Weiner was a strong determine inside St. Peter’s and in Helena. He was incomes $2 million a yr and had threatened to sue the hospital a number of occasions, court docket information present. Whereas his nurses adored him, others inside St. Peter’s feared him. Many on workers credited him with forcing out two hospital CEOs who had challenged his pay, court docket information present.
“If any certainly one of us got here up in opposition to him, we might have been crushed,” LaClair instructed me. “He had an excessive amount of energy and an excessive amount of cash.”
LaClair lastly took his issues to the hospital’s peer evaluate committee, an inner group of docs charged with inspecting questions on affected person care. In early 2020, he turned the committee chair and would lead the trouble to take away Weiner. He acknowledged that he and the hospital waited too lengthy to behave.
In December 2020, St. Peter’s fired Weiner, accusing him of “hurt that was brought about to sufferers by receiving therapies, together with chemotherapy, that weren’t clinically indicated or vital,” amongst different allegations.
Weiner responded by suing the hospital for wrongful termination and defamation. Former sufferers created a Fb group referred to as “We stand with Dr. Tom Weiner” and held the primary of tons of of small protests exterior the hospital. A Montana decide dismissed Weiner’s suit. He filed an enchantment, which is pending with the state Supreme Courtroom.
When Olson discovered that Weiner had been eliminated, he was outraged, satisfied that he’d misplaced a superb medical thoughts, who had been form and given him years he in any other case would by no means have seen. He and his mother and father cheered on the protestors. “I might have been most likely a kind of individuals, on his facet, up till all this blew up and we came upon what was actually occurring,” he instructed me.
Olson didn’t know that his case was amongst dozens that St. Peter’s despatched to exterior medical reviewers on the College of Utah and The Greeley Firm, a well being care consultancy. The reviewers found that Weiner had ordered two bone marrow biopsies in 2011. The primary confirmed indicators of MDS, which researchers lately have discovered is commonly misdiagnosed. Nonetheless, the second, taken 10 months later, indicated no disease.
Weiner shared the damaging biopsy consequence with Olson however instructed him to disregard it; all it proved was that the routine was working. Weiner continued Olson’s chemotherapy.
That second biopsy, on the very least, ought to have prompted extra testing to substantiate or eradicate MDS, the reviewers wrote. It was unclear “why this second bone marrow biopsy consequence was ignored, and why one other bone marrow biopsy was not completed,” the report stated. “The affected person could have been uncovered to the toxicities of those therapies unnecessarily.”
After I questioned Weiner about Olson’s case, he dismissed the reviewers’ conclusion that he ought to have stopped chemotherapy when the follow-up biopsy was damaging. “That doesn’t say you didn’t have the illness,” he stated. “It simply implies that the therapy labored, and it knocked it away. It doesn’t imply you didn’t have it firstly.”
I pressed Weiner. If the chemo had “knocked it away,” wouldn’t that decision for adjusting the therapy? He stated he continued chemo for one more 9 years on the recommendation of specialists on the Mayo Clinic. Olson scoured his medical file and located no proof to help this declare.
After Weiner was gone, Olson obtained one other biopsy, which got here again damaging. St. Peter’s additionally retested the pattern from the primary biopsy. It, too, confirmed that he by no means had MDS. Regardless of the overwhelming proof that Weiner had misdiagnosed and improperly handled Olson, LaClair felt he couldn’t simply say, “Dr. Weiner did this to you.” Information present many Weiner sufferers bristled when instructed to get a second opinion or turned hostile on the suggestion that Weiner had mistreated them.
“The worst a part of the hurt is that they believed in him,” LaClair instructed me. “The hurt that he’s completed to those individuals — they’re damaged each bodily and mentally due to what he did.”
For years, LaClair couldn’t comprehend why so many in Helena proceed to help Weiner, however in watching the change in certainly one of his favourite sufferers, he got here to grasp one thing: Olson didn’t simply really feel betrayed; he was heartbroken. “You wish to hear one thing that basically makes you sick?” LaClair requested. “He stated to me, ‘I simply needed him to say he’s sorry.’”
After receiving chemo via his 30s and into his 40s, Olson’s most cancers therapies have been stopped in early 2021.
In a court filing that yr, the hospital alleged that Weiner “misdiagnosed and/or didn’t correctly diagnose quite a few different sufferers whose subsequent chemotherapy therapies could not have been warranted … .” St. Peter’s, nonetheless, didn’t present a full accounting. The hospital reported that it had suspended Weiner to the state medical board, which declined to remark. Nevertheless it’s unclear whether or not St. Peter’s relayed Olson’s case or any of the opposite misdiagnoses to the board. Hospital directors declined to touch upon the case, although Olson signed a medical privateness waiver granting them permission to speak to me. A spokesperson stated in an announcement that “St. Peter’s is concentrated on shifting ahead, and we stay totally dedicated to offering the good care and expertise our group deserves.”
After I offered Weiner with examples of alleged affected person hurt, he denied that he mistreated anybody and remained unapologetic. He does acknowledge, nonetheless, that Olson suffered for no motive.
“I felt that he had MDS,” Weiner stated. “I used to be persevering with this medication to suppress it and management it for so long as attainable, as a result of he had no different possibility. Clearly, if I knew that he by no means had MDS, I wouldn’t have completed it, however I used to be below the assumption from the experiences and all the things that he ought to proceed it. Now, once more, hindsight says that he acquired it needlessly, and that a part of it, I’m sorry about. I’m.”
For Olson, the acknowledgement that he didn’t have most cancers is 13 years too late. In 2022, he sued St. Peter’s for malpractice. The hospital settled and paid an undisclosed quantity. As a result of Weiner was an worker of St. Peter’s, he was not held liable.
Now not overloaded with iron or receiving chemo, Olson turned eligible for a donor kidney. In the summertime of 2023, he acquired one. He continues to battle with an array of well being points, however he is aware of there’s an opportunity he can dwell into previous age.
Olson tries not to consider what occurred to him. It takes him to a darkish place. He nonetheless desires to see the most effective in individuals, even Weiner. However he typically can’t assist however marvel what motivated his former oncologist. “Did he simply do that for cash?” he requested. “Was he betting on me to die and simply thought he may make more cash?”